Platform comparison

Polymarket vs Kalshi: Regulation, Funding, Fees and Market Structure

Polymarket and Kalshi both offer event contracts whose prices can be read as implied probabilities, but the right comparison depends on which Polymarket product you mean. Kalshi and Polymarket US operate as CFTC-designated contract markets; Polymarket.com is a separate international, blockchain-based product that says it is not CFTC-regulated.

Choose by legal eligibility, funding method, market rules, fees and liquidity—not by a single screenshot of market count or headline odds.

Comparison at a glance

FeaturePolymarket.com internationalPolymarket USKalshi
Primary audienceEligible users outside restricted jurisdictionsEligible U.S. usersEligible U.S. and supported international users under current rules
Regulatory statementOfficial site says not CFTC-regulatedQCX LLC d/b/a Polymarket US is a CFTC DCMKalshiEX LLC is a CFTC DCM
Account relationshipSeparate from Polymarket USSeparate from international productIndependent Kalshi account
Market structurePeer-to-peer order bookU.S. event-contract exchangePeer-to-peer event-contract exchange
Typical payoutWinning share $1, losing share $0Contract-specific rulesWinning contract $1, losing contract $0
Funding emphasisCrypto deposit routes and Polygon collateralU.S. product methodsACH, debit, crypto, wire and other documented methods
ResolutionPublished rules and UMA oracle processU.S. exchange rulesMarket Rules and full Contract Rules

Features change. Verify the live product rather than treating this table as a permanent availability guarantee.

First decide which Polymarket is relevant

This is the most important step. Polymarket’s Help Center says polymarket.com is for eligible international users and excludes U.S. residents. U.S. users use the separate Polymarket US product, whose accounts and support are not connected to the international website.

A U.S. comparison should therefore be Polymarket US vs Kalshi, not an assumption that a U.S. user can trade on the international site. A non-U.S. user may need to compare international eligibility and funding on both platforms.

Do not use a VPN to force access. Product availability is a legal and account condition, not a browser setting.

Regulation and operator identity

The CFTC public register lists:

  • KalshiEX LLC / Kalshi as a designated contract market since November 2020;
  • QCX LLC d/b/a Polymarket US as a designated contract market.

The international Polymarket legal notice states that Polymarket.com operates independently and is not CFTC-regulated.

This does not make one contract profitable or predict which interface will be easier. Regulation establishes a framework for exchange rules, reporting, supervision and enforcement. It does not insure event-contract losses.

Contract pricing is conceptually similar

Both platforms describe binary event contracts that settle at $1 for the winning side and $0 for the losing side. A YES price of 37¢ is commonly read as about 37% implied probability.

For 100 contracts at 37¢:

  • purchase cost: $37 before fees;
  • winning settlement value: $100;
  • gross profit if correct: $63;
  • loss if wrong: $37 plus applicable fees.

That similarity makes prices easy to compare, but contract rules may differ. “Will Candidate X win?” can use different deadlines, certification sources or treatment of replacement candidates. Two prices are comparable only after the rulebooks match.

Market creation and settlement

Polymarket International

The platform team creates markets using published rules and sources. The current documentation says resolution occurs through the UMA Optimistic Oracle. A result is proposed, enters a challenge window and can move into a dispute process.

Kalshi

Kalshi tells users to read both the Market Rules shown under prices and the full Contract Rules. The exchange determines and settles contracts according to those rules.

Why the difference matters

An oracle dispute is not the same process as an exchange determination, even when both depend on published sources. Traders should compare:

  • who makes the final determination;
  • permitted challenge or review process;
  • named evidence source;
  • expected settlement time;
  • treatment of corrections or ambiguity.

Funding and withdrawal experience

Polymarket.com

Current international documentation emphasizes account-specific crypto deposit addresses and supported network routes. Trading collateral uses pUSD on Polygon, backed by USDC. A network mismatch can create recovery risk.

Kalshi

Kalshi’s transfer guide lists debit card, ACH, PayPal, Venmo, Cash App deposits, crypto and wire, with availability varying by location. It says ACH bank transfer is for U.S. users, while international users use a narrower set of supported methods. Security holds and processing times can affect withdrawal availability.

Practical choice

Users who prefer direct U.S. bank funding may find Kalshi’s ACH flow relevant. Crypto-native international users may prefer Polymarket.com’s wallet-based routes. The best method depends on eligibility, cost and the desired withdrawal destination.

Fees require formulas, not slogans

Polymarket’s current international fee schedule charges taker fees on selected categories and no maker fee. Geopolitical markets are currently fee-free. Its formula depends on shares, category rate and price, so it is not a flat percentage of stake.

Kalshi publishes a fee schedule that can change by contract class and date. Its July 2026 schedule states there is no settlement or membership fee, no Kalshi fee for ACH deposits or withdrawals, possible card and third-party crypto charges, and a trade-fee formula documented separately.

Compare total cost for the exact order:

Total cost = explicit trade fee + spread + slippage + funding cost + withdrawal cost − rebates

Never compare “zero deposit fee” on one platform with “trade fee” on another; they are different cost layers.

Liquidity matters more than the market-card percentage

Both are order-driven exchanges. The best-looking probability may be impossible for your full order if depth is thin.

For each platform, record:

  • best bid and ask;
  • spread in cents;
  • shares available at each level;
  • expected average fill for your size;
  • likely exit depth;
  • recent trade activity;
  • applicable explicit fees.

A 1¢ better top price can be worse overall if only ten contracts are available there.

Market selection changes constantly

Comparisons often claim that one venue “has more politics” or “always has better sports markets.” Market catalogs evolve with user demand, regulation and listing decisions. Counts also depend on whether grouped outcomes are treated as one market or many contracts.

For a specific question, compare the live catalogs. For general selection, track several weeks of categories relevant to you rather than relying on a single day.

Data and transparency

Polymarket International exposes public blockchain activity and API documentation, which can help technical users analyze orders and positions. On-chain visibility does not automatically identify every person or explain intent.

Kalshi offers market data and developer resources within its exchange framework. Data format, historical depth, rate limits and licensing should be checked for the intended use.

For research, the better platform is the one whose data covers the needed contract with consistent rules—not automatically the one with the larger brand.

Account verification and security

Kalshi’s public guide says users must meet eligibility requirements including identity verification. Polymarket US also operates under its own U.S. onboarding and compliance rules. International Polymarket uses separate login and wallet flows and can request information under its terms.

Security priorities differ:

  • bank/card accounts: protect email, password, MFA and linked financial methods;
  • wallet accounts: protect seed phrase, private key and transaction approvals;
  • both: verify domains, resist fake support and keep transaction records.

No official support agent needs a seed phrase or six-digit login code.

Which platform fits which user?

Consider Polymarket US if:

  • you are an eligible U.S. user;
  • its live contract catalog matches your interests;
  • its current funding and fee rules suit you;
  • you want the Polymarket-branded U.S. product.

Consider Kalshi if:

  • you want its specific CFTC-regulated contract catalog;
  • U.S. bank funding is important;
  • its rules, fees and liquidity are better for the contract;
  • its available transfer methods match your location.

Consider Polymarket.com if:

  • you are eligible outside restricted jurisdictions;
  • you understand crypto funding and Polygon risks;
  • its international markets and oracle model suit your needs;
  • you accept wallet and smart-contract responsibilities.

These are filters, not recommendations.

A contract-by-contract decision scorecard

Score each venue from 0 to 2:

Factor012
EligibilityNot eligibleUnclearClearly eligible
Rule clarityAmbiguousSome edge casesClear source and cutoff
SpreadWideModerateTight
Depth for sizeInsufficientPartialStrong
Total feeHigh/unclearAcceptableLow/clear
Funding pathIncompatibleUsableConvenient
Settlement processUnclearUnderstandableStrong fit

Do not compensate for ineligibility with a high score elsewhere.

How we verified this comparison

We used Polymarket’s official product and fee documentation, Kalshi’s official prediction-market, transfer and fee pages, and CFTC records for both U.S. designated contract markets. We avoided live market-count claims that would become stale quickly.

Frequently asked questions

Is Kalshi more regulated than Polymarket?

Kalshi and Polymarket US operators are CFTC-designated contract markets. Polymarket.com is a separate international product that says it is not CFTC-regulated.

Can U.S. users choose Polymarket.com instead of Polymarket US?

No. The international terms prohibit U.S. persons from trading there. U.S. users should use the U.S. product if eligible.

Which has lower fees?

It depends on the exact contract, maker/taker status, price, funding method and current schedule. Calculate total cost from the live order preview.

Are identical questions priced the same?

Not necessarily. Different participants, liquidity and contract rules can produce different prices.

Which platform is safer?

Safety depends on product regulation, account controls, custody method and user behavior. Regulation does not prevent market losses; wallet self-custody does not prevent malicious signatures.

Official sources

Risk notice: Event contracts can lose their full purchase value. Eligibility, funding and fees differ by product and location.

Update log

  • November 17, 2026: Rechecked DCM records, product access, funding options and July 2026 fee disclosures.
Polymarket Central Comparison Desk

Reviewed by Regulatory and Product Source Review. Updated November 17, 2026. Risk level: High.